We are now in-network with UHC and Cigna! Coming soon:  In-network with Aetna in 2026!

We are now in-network with Aetna, UHC, Cigna, NYU Student Plans, Carelon OON benefits, and select Emblem plans!

Identifying and Challenging Food Rules

Food rules may seem protective, but they often trap you in restrictive eating patterns that disconnect you from your body’s needs. Rooted in diet culture, misinformation, or fear, these rules can lead to guilt, shame, and anxiety around food. Challenging them is key to healing your relationship with food and rebuilding trust in your body. Understanding where these rules come from and ultimately breaking them allows for a more flexible, nourishing approach to eating. Eating disorder recovery is about finding freedom, starting with letting go of the rules that no longer serve you.

What Is A Food Rule?

Food rules are beliefs about food that stem from external influences rather than your own internal cues. They often include a sense of obligation, meaning the rule may not reflect what you truly want but what you feel you “should” be doing. While someone struggling with an eating disorder may have different rules compared to someone else, here are five examples of food rules:

  • “I shouldn’t eat after 7:00 p.m.”
  • “I can’t have dessert every day.”
  • “I should not snack between meals.”
  • “I should avoid carbs.”
  • “I should wait to eat lunch until 1:00 p.m.”

How to Identify a Food Rule

It Brings Feelings of Guilt or Shame

Like breaking a rule as a child, breaking a food rule can lead to feelings of guilt or shame. If you are feeling negative emotions after eating, you may be able to inquire into the feelings and identify a food rule. Try asking yourself, “What about that eating experience is making me feel like I did something wrong?”

It Started From a Diet

Diets rely on making up their own rules, allowing the companies selling you things to blame you when you don’t get the results they promised. They can blame you for not following their protocol instead of acknowledging that there is abundant scientific evidence to show that diets do not work. Often, the rules that people adopt from diets stay with them long after they’ve decided to “stop” the diet itself.

There is No Fact to Support It

Food rules are often introduced or marketed as the “magic bullet” to answer your body concerns or weight loss desires. However, they are almost never rooted in facts. So, seeking out the facts and talking to your dietitian is important. If you are reading studies, look into who is funding the research. Is it a company or an entity interested in selling you a diet product?

Tips for Starting to Unlearn Food Rules

Talk It Out! Fact Check

It’s important to be open about your struggles and feelings with your Registered Dietitian and treatment team. Vet your sources, especially the ones you find online. It is also important to always be cautious when you come across be wary of functional medicine doctors and nutritionists who are not Registered Dietitians. 

Break the Food Rule – Take the Opposite Action

This one is easier said than done, but starting small and going at your own pace is okay. For example, with the help of your treatment team, pick one food rule from your list and break it Then, break it again. And again. Be curious and observe what happens when you break the rule. What emotions come up the first time you break the rule? What about the second? How are your feelings changing as you repeat the action of breaking the rule?

Re-Frame with Positive Thoughts

Pick one food rule from your list and write it down. Then, write down three positive thoughts underneath the rule – even if you don’t totally believe the positive thoughts yet. Keep following this idea in a journal or the Notes app on your phone. You can return to these positive thoughts when you hear the “food police” pop in your head. This step will help your brain to make this process more natural.

Eating Disorder Recovery at BALANCE

BALANCE eating disorder treatment center™, located in New York City, offers free consultation calls to help you explore next steps. We provide in-person programming seven days a week and are in-network with UnitedHealthcare (UHC), Cigna, Emblem, and Oscar, with Aetna coverage coming soon. Support is available, and recovery is possible. Schedule a free consultation call with our admissions team here and stay connected with BALANCE on Instagram here.

References

  1. Harrison, C. (2019). Anti-diet: Reclaim your time, money, well-being and happiness through intuitive eating. Little, Brown Spark. 
  2. Harrison, C. (2023). The wellness trap: Break free from diet culture, disinformation, and dubious diagnoses–and find your true well-being. Little, Brown Spark. 
  3. Hilton, R. (2022, February 12). How to Recognize and Break Food Rules—NourishRX | The Blog. https://nourishrx.com/how-to-break-food-rules/

This post was written by Therapy Intern Claire Poneman (she/her).

Claire Poneman (she/her) is a therapy intern at BALANCE from Northern Virginia. Claire is pursuing her Master of Social Work (MSW) at Smith College School for Social Work. In her free time, Claire enjoys traveling, trying new restaurants, and painting. She is excited to be interning at BALANCE and to work with BALANCE clients on their recovery journeys.

Secret Link